By Alan Fletcher -
Carpet Expert and Consumer Advocate
18. Can you tell me more about recycled P.E.T. Polyester carpet? What are your opinions on this new fiber? I have a very active home (4 inside dogs, 2 kids, traffic, traffic, traffic) and I am considering purchasing this carpet for my living room and hallway. What do you think?
A. Thank you for your question! This is one of my favorite questions to answer, as this is not a new fiber at all! P.E.T. (Polyethylene
Terephthalate) is polyester produced from recycled soft drink bottles, and has been available for years. Here is my take on this fiber:
While polyester is a very soft synthetic fiber, and it is available in wonderful colors, polyester fibers will mat down quickly and is very hard to clean. It sounds to me like you really need a carpet that cleans easy.
The main problem is that the pile will easily mat down and crush. That means in areas where there is heavy traffic, like down the hallway, polyester carpets will mat down quickly and never come back to its original appearance. In your case, with kids and pets I bet within six months you would be very unhappy with your polyester carpeting.
Do not listen to the advice of carpet sales people who recommend polyester, no matter what they say!
Because polyester is so cheap to make, carpet manufacturers have tried for years to make a good carpet out of polyester, with limited success. every year they come up with some new technique that they claim will make polyester more durable. It hasn't happened yet.
What I do recommend is for you to buy Nylon! Nylon carpet is more expensive than polyester, but it will tolerate an incredible amount of abuse. It cleans easily and won't mat down like polyester. Buy a continuous filament 100% nylon carpet and you will be much happier in the long run!
19. Does face weight have any bearing on the quality of the carpet?
A. Carpet face-weights
do have bearing on the
quality of carpet but not with every type of carpet. Let me explain. face weight
is the amount of fiber that is used to make the carpet. I am sure that you have
seen thin carpets and thick carpets, the thicker the nap (fibers) the higher the
face weight. Just because a carpet is thicker doesn't mean it will last longer
or wear better.
The key to longevity is in the fiber. Nylon is the toughest, longest
lasting, most durable, resilient, easiest cleaning fiber of all. A thin carpet
made of nylon is just as good as a thick carpet made of nylon, because the fiber
is durable. On the other hand, Polyester is a fiber that is not resilient, not
easy to clean, non durable fiber. The manufacturers of carpet have to make it of
high face weight in order to try to make it last longer, and be more durable. It
generally doesn't work out well.
My suggestion to you is to buy a carpet
made of nylon, of the best quality you can afford in order to get the best bang
for your buck. I would stay away from polyester carpets at all costs! They just
don't last.
As far as how they gauge the face-weight of
carpets, you need to know that there is a lot of confusion about how each
manufacturer determines their actual face weight. Unfortunately I cannot give
you the formula because they all use different methods. Some use just the weight
of the fibers, others use the weight of the backing and the fibers. When I look
at a carpet I want to see tightly twisted tufts, closely packed together like a
dense forest, and difficult to see the backing when I spread the tufts apart
with my fingers.
20. How do I install carpet on my indoor stairs (steps). How do
I go about completing this job?
A. Putting carpet on stairs will require a professional to measure and install.
You should contact a qualified carpet installer to help you with this. Carpet
manufacturers do not offer any warranty for carpets installed on stairs.
21. How well does Berber withstand high traffic areas?
Is it easy to keep clean and what kind of padding is the best? I am going crazy
trying to decide if I want a plush carpet or Berber. I have a newborn son and
know I will soon have lots of messes to clean up! Thank you for responding at
your earliest convenience.
A. Berber can be made of Nylon or Olefin, and of the two, Nylon would be the
better choice. Berber is a nice looking carpet, and can be quite reasonably
priced. However, It is not the best choice for folks with kids or pets. A good
Nylon plush would clean easily, wear better, and retain its new appearance much
longer than would a Berber. If you must buy a Berber be sure to select one with
small loops, the big loops fall over quickly and look bad sooner. As far as pad
goes, a 6 pound, 7/16" rebond pad for the plush, or an 8 pound 1/4"
for the Berber.
22. I think they sent me the wrong carpet, what do I do now?
I just purchased some nylon Berber carpet. However, the weave or loop
is much larger than the sample and I have concerns about the nylon pulling. I
like the smaller loop. The larger looks like the yarns has been snagged or
pulled. I found you web site very helpful, but what happens when the carpet comes in
and it does not appear to be the same weave, or loop that was selected?
A. You should always inspect your new carpet
as soon as it arrives at your home, before they begin to install it. If you have ordered
carpet from a carpet retailer and the carpet does not closely match the carpet
sample, you have every right to refuse the carpet. You should get exactly what
you ordered, so contact the retailer and ask them to look into it.
If there is a
noticeable difference they should reorder the carpet and there should not be any
additional cost to you. In many cases they will deny your claims and say that
the difference is insignificant and the carpet falls within normal manufacturing
specifications.
23. I am looking for a good quality carpet that can withstand kids, cats,
dogs and traffic.
I have a somewhat formal living room that you land in upon entering my house. To get to any other part of the house at that point, one
needs to walk through that living room. My biggest problem is the traffic marks from the front door, across the living room and down the hallway to
the bedrooms. This gets dirty fast. Any help would be appreciated.
A. There is only one type of carpet that can potentially withstand all these
things, it is Nylon. A textured plush style will hide the footprints and show
dirt the least, depending on the color you select. Select a dense carpet with at
least 40 oz face weight, this will better withstand the traffic.
A good tuft-twist at least five twists per inch is important to keep your carpet looking
new longer. It must have anti stain. You will need to vacuum regularly at least
every other day, and have the carpet cleaned when it gets dirty, once or twice a
year. You might want to consider laying down a plastic runner in the heavy
traffic areas. Stay away from looped styles of carpet like Berber and never buy
Polyester carpet (P.E.T.) no matter what they tell you.
24. I have read that the new PET fiber is even more stain resistant than
nylon. Your web site indicated PET is the worst. Can you refer me to any other
authorities?
A. Whether or not it is more stain resistant than Nylon is not the issue, it
is that P.E.T. Polyester carpets mat down quickly and have poor resiliency. That
means that Polyester carpet will not retain a new appearance very long. Clean it
all you like, it will still be matted down. Nylon has excellent resiliency and
will look new longer and it cleans well too.
25. I want to replace my family room carpet with a different color, but not
the bedroom. What do you do where the two carpets meet?
A. The carpet layer would seam the two carpets together at the doorway between
the two rooms. Even if the two carpet colors are very different it doesn't
usually look bad, it is very common to have different colors of carpet
throughout the house.
26. What
is the best type of carpet you recommend for a older dog?
I am thinking of purchasing a Mohawk carpet, the heavier weight one
that is made out of the recycled plastics. I have been told that this is easy to
clean, but I thought that nylon was the easiest to spot clean? I have an older
dog that does have urine accidents and this is what I am faced with. I plan on
putting down a moisture barrier pad, that I think will help w/the cleaning. What
is the best type of carpet you recommend for this situation?
A. The recycled plastic carpet you mentioned is made of polyester the worst
fiber to make carpet from. Please don't buy polyester, you will not be happy
with it. You need to buy nylon, with stain resisting treatment applied. Don't
spend a lot on the carpets where your dog will be mostly, because if your dog
does his duty often your carpet will not survive very long. Although nylon
cleans the best, dog urine never completely comes out. Don't spend a lot on
special pad, whether urine is on it or in it won't make that much of a
difference. You are better off sealing your floors underneath so the urine
doesn't soak into the wood or concrete. Trust me, I am a firsthand expert on pet
urine. If you need more info on this procedure let me know.
27. What carpet pad is best? Rubber, Rebond or Fiber?
I am shopping for new carpeting to be installed over a dry concrete
floor. Every salesperson gives us a different recommendation for the padding.
What is best? Rubber, Rebond or Fiber?
A. Your question is a valid one, and most salespeople do not have a clue
about what pad is right for your needs. I need to know more before I can answer
your pad question.
1. What type of carpet are you buying? Berber, plush? frieze?
2. How long do you plan on this carpet lasting?
3. Might you be selling your home soon?
4. What fiber will the carpet be made of?
5. Do you have kids or pets?
6. What is the estimated price of the carpet are you buying? ($10, $20, $30, $40
per yard?)
Follow up:
Thanks for your reply.
1. Plush Mohawk Signature
2. 10 years
3. Not planning to sell home soon
4. Probably Polyester, but maybe
Nylon
5. No kids or pets
6. $13 / yard
Although our basement does not have a water problem, we have been told by
some salespeople that "rebond" will grab and hold moisture, and
transmit it to the carpet. Others have told us that "rebond" is better because it will
allow the padding and carpet to breathe. And rubber will cause moisture to
accumulate between the pad and concrete and cause mildew.
Follow-up answer:
A. Based on your reply I believe that you have a two-fold problem.
First, considering buying a polyester carpet and hoping it lasts 10 years is
unrealistic. Polyester is the WORST fiber to make carpet from. It mats down
quickly and will look horrible within a year or two.
Second, you have retail salespeople that are unaware of the truth and are giving
you false information. If your basement is dry you have nothing to worry about.
Rubber padding is expensive and is a great pad. Even in a basement. The truth
is, that rebond pad is great too, but it is much less expensive.
If I were
buying carpet for my basement, I would definitely buy the Nylon carpet, and use
a 6-pound, 7/16" inch thick, Rebond pad. Expect to pay about $300- $4.25 per yard for
the pad. Forget buying rubber, it is not worth the extra money.
Anyone who tries to sell you polyester is not giving you good advice. If you
want your carpet to last ten years, buy Nylon and stick with a plush style.
The only other viable option I would suggest is a small-looped Berber made of Olefin,
using a 1/4 inch 8 Lb. rebond pad, since you have no kids or pets.
Follow-up reply:
Well, went back to the same dealer, and they insisted that polyester /
rubber was the way to go. All the other dealers in our town agreed with you, so
I went to another dealer, got 100% nylon with 8lb rebond, and paid a cheaper
price to boot! Thanks again for your help.
28. What carpet is best for a family room with heavy
traffic?
We are considering carpeting a family room with either Master's
Choice - style Chokio, which is rated for heavy use, face weight of 52 ounces,
twist of 7.5, and density of 1910 made of 100% DuPont Stainmaster Xtra Life
Nylon, or: Traffic-master (Wear-Dated Carpet II) style Pacesetter , rated about
3.7 for performance (at high end of active traffic wear), 100 % Solutia
Wear-Dated II Nylon, twist of 3.85, density of 3.772, and face weight of 72
ounces. Would greatly appreciate your opinion. There are no children in our
household, and this is a low traffic area.
A. Given your application and low traffic situation, either selection would
be a great one. You are considering two wonderful quality carpets. They both
have the capability to last a lifetime if cared for. If it were me, I would
select the least expensive (Master's Choice) of the two, and then take
little vacation with the savings. You have done your homework well, good job!
Follow-up reply:
Thank you so much for replying so promptly and with specific information.
I now feel more confident about my choice (which will be the Master's
Choice as you suggested). Really appreciate this service! Read
More
It's
getting hard to find a reputable carpet dealer these days! That's why I've
created a special hand-picked list of over 350 locally owned Carpet Dealers
who offer Free estimates, fair prices, knowledgeable staff, honest measuring
and qualified installers, And my personal recommendation! It doesn't get any
better than that! See
My Recommended Carpet Dealers Near You!
Alan's
Preferred
Carpet Dealers
Carpet Buying
Guide
by Alan Fletcher - The
Carpet Professor!
